Nitzken Insurance Agency

Here for you since 1946

Providing protection to our community since 1946

For over 75 years, Nitzken Insurance Agency has continued to provide peace of mind and protection for our clients and their families throughout our community. Our fourth-generation agency founded by Elmer J. Nitzken Sr. centers around community relationships, professionalism and insurance expertise. We consistently advocate for our clients by providing specific coverage options tailored to fit each individual. Let us help you with all your insurance needs.

Reviews from our clients


“Gary and Shelby have always provided the absolute top quality service. Been a client for over 15 years, and while we rarely have to interact when I do have a problem, it is immediately addressed/resolved. Service is above and beyond; could not be happier as a client!”

-client since 1997


“My entire family has worked very closely with the Nitzken’s. They treat you as family from the first phone call and will always leave you feeling at ease with each meeting. They take the time to explain everything in simple terms so you can fully understand the insurance lingo. I would recommend this family business to any and everyone!”

-client since 2018


“Shelby is quite a pleasure to work with. She always takes the time to answer all of our questions in a very prompt and timely manner. We would highly recommend them.”

-client since 2020


Here for you, always

We are a fourth-generation insurance agency who takes great pride in our family business, local community and relationships. As an Independent Agency, we partner with multiple insurance carriers and offer a wide variety of coverages. We strive to provide a high level of service where you work directly with your insurance agent in order to deliver true risk management solutions. Working closely with our clients allows us to identify insurance products that best fit each person’s unique needs. We understand you have a choice when choosing your insurance provider. Nitzken Insurance is here to offer that exceptional customer service and sense of security to protect your most valuable assets.

Get in Touch